Eagle Reverse Rarity 6

Currency:USD Category:Coins & Paper Money Start Price:0.00 USD Estimated At:2,000.00 - 3,000.00 USD
Eagle Reverse Rarity 6
11,000.00USD+ (2,200.00) buyer's premium + applicable fees & taxes.
This item SOLD at 2021 Mar 11 @ 21:50UTC-8 : PST/AKDT
Lot: 3088
Year: 1854
Denom: 50C
Title: Eagle Reverse
Rarity 6

Description: 1854 round Half Dol., BG-436, Eagle Reverse, Die State II (“period” die defect after date, “exclamation point” defect above period after DOL.). PCGS MS63. Rarity 6. Unusual Liberty head with coarse curls and hollow neck, 13 stars around; eagle with shield and branch, but no scroll (!), HALF DOL. 1854 around. A somewhat amateurish effort by a second unknown maker (“Unknown Maker B”). Perhaps the work of Auguste Dubois, as surmised by the cataloger in the second edition of California Pioneer Fractional Gold. (His name is spelled “Auguste Duboice” in the San Francisco Herald; “Augustine Dubois” in the Sacramento Daily Union; “Augustin Dubois” in the Placer Times & Transcript (the latter two citations courtesy of indefatigable Gold Rush researcher Dan Owens); and “A. Duboce” in LeCount & Strong’s San Francisco City Directory for the year 1854. Mr. Dubois, who had a partner named John Waschwald or Oswald, operated out of a house on the southeast corner of Green and Fayette Streets with all the windows blacked out except one. The pair were accused of counterfeiting, and when this house was searched by the San Francisco police, a secret room was discovered in the cellar that held a rolling machine, furnace, crucibles, and a large amount of melted gold. When they returned to it, Auguste and John were arrested, but made bail and the charges were dismissed as false three days later. Mr. Dubois stated to the police that he had been a gold pen maker in New York, where he was from, and that his equipment was used for that purpose.

While that may have been his intention in coming to California, upon seeing small California gold in circulation he was probably tempted to join the party, since he had all the necessary equipment (except a screw press, and he probably had that also but omitted in the newspaper accounts). In any case, there seems to be no other suitable candidate for a maker for the year 1854 only. “Unknown Maker B” also made octagonal dollars dated 1854. Lustrous, Sharply struck Brilliant Uncirculated. PCGS MS63 Eagle William C. O’Connor (PCGS# 10472). (Note: PCGS seems to have dished this piece in pushing it into the holder – hope I’m wrong.) PCGS POP 5 + 0.
Low Estimate: 2000
High Estimate: 3000
Grading Co: PCGS
Gr: MS
Gr2: 63
PCGS#: 10472
Cert#: 40625063
Pedigree/Collection: The William C. O'Connor Collection