SOLD
10,000.00USDto t*****3+ buyer's premium (1,750.00)
This item SOLD at 2017 Sep 16 @ 00:03UTC-7 : PDT/MST
Did you win this lot?
A full invoice should be emailed to the winner by the auctioneer within a day or two.
DON’T FORGET!
You get 1% of your purchases back as
credit towards your next two Kagin’s Auctions!
From our 3/11 HKA auction described as:
“Large presentation ingot for a celebration honoring William Sharon "by his old friends of the Comstock Lode,” 1876. This ingot was made for all-out surprise celebration for Sharon and his friends. This ingot is blank where the others we have seen have the attendees name engraved at the bottom of the obverse of the ingot. Nineteen of these ingots were reportedly made for each of the attendees and a 20th for William Sharon. 6.13 Troy ounces. Approximately 6.25” X 4” and 1+ mm thick.
The Story
The party was at the Palace Hotel, built by Sharon`s old boss, William Chapman Ralston. Ralston had committed suicide several months earlier after the Bank of California`s failure in 1875. It was at one time the largest and most powerful bank in the United States. The Bank had made it through the failure with the help of Sharon and friends. Reports said the affair had all the accoutrements of an inaugural ball but was exceptionally private. Flowers were everywhere. The Palace Hotel manager, Mr. Warren Leland, was told to spare no expense, according to an article that appeared in the "San Francisco Examiner" the next day. It reported:
"It is fair to presume that the grand dinner spread in honor of William Sharon, in the Palace Hotel, on Tuesday Evening, has never been equaled in good taste or elegant surroundings on this continent. An enthusiast might say that `it was fit for the gods` and it is doubtful whether there would be an exaggeration in such an assertion… No public announcement of the intended gathering was given, and Mr. Sharon was ignorant of the arrangements until he was escorted into the banquet hall."
The paper went on to report the attendees were all old friends of Sharon`s "long before he found the means to build up a fortune." Twenty men sat at a single table. D. O. Mills, sat at one end, and General John F. Miller, of the Alaska Commercial Company, sat at the other. Judge Heydenfeldt was seated at Miller`s left. Seated down the two sides were people who will be a familiar lot to those students of early Comstock history: Thomas Bell, William Lent, and W. Alvord, all part of the original Gould & Curry Company; William Morris Stewart, champion Comstock lawyer and later Senator; Wood A. Head and Bob Morrow, all early claim stakers on the Comstock from Nevada City and Grass Valley; J. Sahaw, J. Skae, both mine superintendents on the Comstock (Morrow was also supt. of the Savage); and G. S. Dodge, A. Gansl, A. Selover. Sta. Marina, D. L. Bliss and Steinhart. Apparently, while the men celebrated and told stories to one another, a band played nearby. There were no speeches; the party was a simple celebration of friendship in its grandest form.
The ingots were so exciting to the men and news media, that they were described in detail in the "Examiner". It reported that "At each plate were glasses for eight different kinds of wine. The napkins were folded flat, and on each was a delicate bouquet. Beneath the napkin was a bill of fare engraved on solid silver, dug from the Comstock lode, and highly polished. These measured about 6 1/4 by 4 1/4 inches… On the front of this novel and costly affair was inscribed in ornamental text and script…" words about the celebration and the menu fit for a king. An observer "laughingly remarked… Everybody went away from the dinner with a silver brick in his hat."
The silver ingot was the perfect gift for all the attendees. Nearly all the men were heavily involved in mining at one time. Most were on the Comstock at the beginning. A very fresh story would have been shared about silver ingots, told by Senator Wm. Morris Stewart. Stewart had headed a bunch of investors along with John P. Jones in the mines at Panamint, California. In 1875 they pulled out a million in silver, but were acutely aware of highwaymen just waiting for the bullion laden wagons to come down the treacherous canyons out of the Panamints. The mountains were so rugged, that there is about 6000 feet of relief in just over a mile of horizontal distance. Even the mighty Wells Fargo & Co. would not dare to establish an express office there for fear the risk of robbery was too high. Stewart related "They said they wouldn`t run any risks at Panamint, not with that bunch of highwaymen lying around just waiting to swoop down and gobble up every dollar in sight." Stewart needed a plan. He said, "Finally I hit on a scheme. I had some molds made in which a ball of solid silver could be run weighing 750 pounds. Then I began smelting the ore, and I ran out enormous cannon balls of the precious stuff that could have bombarded a battleship. When the road agents saw what I was doing, their eyes stuck out of their heads. They acted as though I had cheated them out of property… ." It was a very clever plan indeed.
There are many incidences surrounding William Sharon`s rise to power. Sharon was the manager of the Bank of California in Virginia City who had been handpicked by Ralston. He was a man who knew failure, and Ralston felt Sharon was not likely to want to fail again. Ralston told his Board that Sharon was the best poker player he had ever known. Ralston knew Sharon could beat any of the Board at any game of business they chose, so that`s why Ralston thought Sharon should head the Virginia City office. He would be the best manager of money and bank affairs they could every hope for.
There was a crash on mining stocks in May, 1872, which persisted until 1875. Another stock panic hit in August, 1875, which crushed the Bank of California, once considered "the strongest banking institution on the Pacific Coast." The great bonanzas of the Crown Point and others were only temporary fixes in a stock market that was wild with excitement and activity. There was a run on the Bank of California on August 26, 1875. They closed on the 26th. Ralston had surrendered the Palace Hotel, one of his jewels which was not yet finished, to Sharon on the 25th. He had absolute confidence in Sharon. George Lyman wrote in Ralston`s Ring, "They were closer than brothers". Ralston surrendered all of his personal property to the Bank for the benefit of the depositors. But he was deceived. That day, Ralston had not a friend, as the entire Board turned against him, and left the bank in resignation. He would never return. Mills was instructed to tell Ralston of his dismissal, which was done the next day. In the afternoon, he walked into the ocean and never came out alive. In the ensuing crash, the value of the mines of the Comstock shrunk to one thirtieth of their value that they had been on Jan 1, 1875. D. O. Mills, the first president of the Bank of California, when it was organized in 1864, became president once again, and secured the funding necessary for the Bank`s reopening, which was on October 2. Sharon was a huge asset, tying up loose ends in Nevada and San Francisco. The stock exchanges in San Francisco also closed because of financial panic, reopened on October 5. The Bank went on to great success and is alive today. Sharon also took over and managed Ralston`s estate for his widow and children.
Our consignor from the 3/11 sale inherited this ingot and mirror from her grandmother, who had been given it from a manager at the Palace Hotel, along with a matching ladies’ bathroom (toiletry) silver set of mirror, hair brush and comb. After the Sharon dinner had been completed and the guests had left the building, the hotel manager and several co-workers were given the left-over non-personalized ingots as a souvenir of their work for the hotel. The other two silver toiletry items in the family from the Palace were lost over time.
This story confirms what we thought long ago: that Schreve & Co. of San Francisco made extra ingots for the Sharon dinner in case any dignitaries were invited at the last minute. To date, three of the non-personalized ingots have shown up (including this piece), each with engraving exactly matching the personalized pieces.
The William Sharon Dinner Plate Ingot remains one of the most important keep-sakes of western business and politics, joining both the financial center of the West (San Francisco) and one of its political , banking and mining heavyweights, William Sharon.
Summary
This ingot is important not only because of its rarity and of its presentation value to William Sharon, but because of what it represents. It is a remnant of an important turning point in California financial history, recognizing the great mines of the Comstock, the great bankers of California, and the ingenuity of American financiers in general - all at once. There would have been sad discussion of Ralston`s tragedy, but happiness abounded at that dinner at the success of the Palace Hotel, just completed, and of Sharon`s election to the Senate over his bitter rival James G. Fair, one of the Comstock kings. They would have discussed the old times on the Comstock in 1859-60, and their luck in California during the Gold Rush.
Although this particular ingot is blank, it is unquestionably authentic because it is identical in every way to those I have seen previously (we`ve never published a detailed photograph of these ingots.)
Regardless of the lack of an engraved name, this ingot remains one of the great silver presentation pieces of the nineteenth century. It encompasses everything about the nineteenth century West – one of the great Comstock financiers and bankers, a celebration of mining in the West and the incredible splash that the wealthy used at the time. This is one of three in excellent condition known today that have changed hands publicly, though one of the three has a hole in it. It is a treasure whose appearance is not likely to be duplicated anytime soon. “
After spirited bidding, this artifact brought $16,450
Ex: HKA 3/16/11:2366
Auction Location:
5001 Great America Pkwy, Santa Clara, California, 95051, United States
Previewing Details:
auctions.kagins.com
Sales Tax on currency to non-dealers and coins under $1500 shipped to CA or $1000 to MD per tax accountant
Taxes:
| Tax | Rate | Desc. |
| CA |
6% |
California Sales Tax |
Buyer's Premiums:
| From (Incl.) | To (Excl.) | Premium |
| 0.00 |
Infinite |
17.5% |
Additional Fees:
Shipping Details:
Please allow 5-10 business once payment clears for you purchase to ship. Extra shipping charges for PO Boxes, Overnight, or International shipments.
Payment Details:
Invoice due upon receipt. Please allow up to 5-10 business days to ship once payment posts. There is an automatic 2.5% discount from auction fees when invoices are paid by cash or cash equivalent making your buyer’s fee still only 17.5%. Otherwise, the standard 20% buyer’s fee applies. Please make checks payable to Kagin’s, Inc.
Don’t forget, Kagin’s Auctions Loyalty Program gives you 1% of your invoice subtotal towards your next auction purchase! See Terms & Conditions for more details.
Bank Wire Instructions:
Name of Bank:
Wells Fargo Bank
Address:
1500 Tiburon Blvd.
Tiburon, CA 94920 U.S.A.
Name of the account:
Kagin’s, Inc.
Address:
1550 – G Tiburon Blvd. #201
Tiburon, CA 94920 U.S.A.
Kagin’s Account Number:
995 8039449
Routing number:
121 000 248
SWIFT CODE WFBIUS6S
Auctioneer reserves the right to void an invoice if payment in full is not received within 7 days after the close of the Auction.
If any Auction invoice submitted by Auctioneer is not paid in full when due, the unpaid balance will bear interest at the highest rate permitted by law from the date of invoice until paid.
Any invoice not paid when due will bear a three percent (3%) late fee on the invoice amount.
Accepted Payment Methods:
- VISA
- Master Card
- AMEX
- Money Order/Bank Draft
- Check/Cheque
- COD (cash on delivery)
- See Payment Details
- Wire Transfer
Terms and Conditions of Sale
1. Auction Company. This public auction is being presented by Kagin’s Auctions, a division of Kagin’s, Inc. (“KA”)
2. Binding Effect of Terms and Conditions. These Terms and Conditions are legally binding on anyone that registers
to bid, or actually does bid, at a KA auction. They define the relationship between bidders and KA before, during and after
the auction, and limit KA’s liability to bidders.
3. Consignors and Reserves. This catalog contains descriptions of property belonging to many persons known as
consignors. KA is not required to divulge to prospective bidders the identity of any consignor, except as provided by these
Terms and Conditions. KA’s relationship with a consignor is governed by a separate Consignment Contract, the terms of
which KA is not required to disclose to prospective bidders. The Consignment Contract may permit a consignor to bid on his
or her own lots and pay commissions if successful. If a consignor bids from the floor for his or her own lots, KA may so note
to all present. KA reserves the right to omit from its published prices realized the purchase prices of items re-purchased by
their consignor(s).
4. Who Can and Cannot Bid. Persons may bid at a KA auction in person, by an agent or employee, by telephone
of fax, or by mail, provided that they obtain a catalog and complete either a registration card (if bidding in person) or the
bid sheet contained in the catalog (if bidding by other method). KA reserves the right to reject bids from any person in its
sole discretion. In particular, KA will not accept bids from corporate bidders unless an officer, director or principal of the
corporation agrees in writing to personally guarantee payment. Likewise, bids will be accepted from persons under age
18 only if a parent or legal guardian agrees in writing to accept these Terms and Conditions and be responsible for any
purchases by the bidder. In addition, KA may require bidders without established credit with KA to furnish satisfactory
credit references or deposit such amount as KA may require in its sole and absolute discretion before bidding. Such deposits
will be applied to purchases and unused portions returned after the auction. Finally, for the protection of mail bidders no
“unlimited” or “buy” bids will be accepted.
5. Conflicts of Interest. KA, its principals, and affiliated or related companies and their employees, officers or
principals may either consign to, or bid at, an KA auction and pay commissions. In addition, these persons or entities may
loan or advance funds to consignors and/or prospective bidders, and may thereby acquire interests in items sold at a KA
auction. To the extent that actual or apparent conflicts of interest are created by such situations, bidders consent to such
conflicts.
6. Disclaimer of Representations or Warranties from KA. The descriptions of items in this catalog are qualified
statements of good faith opinion and not warranties. KA relies on the opinions of leading third party certification services,
and supplies information relating to certified items only for the convenience of mail, telephone and fax bidders. Floor
bidders are deemed to have viewed the lots they bid upon. The attributes of particular items may have a material impact
on their value, and bidders assume all risk of differing opinions thereof. No employee or agent of KA is authorized to make
any representations or warranties regarding the characteristics of items sold by KA or the correctness of catalog descriptions,
and KA DISCLAIMS ANY WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS TO THE MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS OR CONDITION OF
ITEMS BEING SOLD.
7. Title. KA relies on representations and warranties from its consignors that the consignors own the items consigned and
are legally entitled to sell those items. Bidders are entitled to rely on those same representations and warranties in making
their purchases, but are encouraged to make their own investigations in case of doubt.
8. Viewing. KA allows potential bidders to examine items to be auctioned during general viewing periods or, at KA’s
discretion, by special appointment. KA encourages floor bidders to examine items before bidding on them.
9. Bidding at Auction. The auction shall take place at the time and place set forth in this catalog, or at some other
time and place as KA may, in its sole discretion, determine. The auctioneer will offer lots in number sequence within each
auction session, subject to KA’s right to withdraw any lot at any time. Only entire lots will be offered unless the auctioneer
directs otherwise. Bidding will open at an amount set by the auctioneer in his or her sole discretion (including by reducing
a mail bid to a level the auctioneer deems appropriate), and will continue at such increments as the auctioneer directs until
the auctioneer declares the lot sold. The auctioneer may accept or decline any bid in his sole discretion, and where more
than one identical bid is received for an item, the auctioneer may prefer the first bid received and may prefer a mail bid over
an identical floor bid. In case of any disputes regarding the existence or amount of bids the auctioneer may rescind the sale
of that lot and re-sell it, or otherwise direct disposition of the lot in his sole discretion. In all cases, the auctioneer’s decision
shall be final. KA IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ERRORS IN BIDDING, and mistaken bids will not justify rescission of a sale.
00_Sep2017_WCA_FrMatter.indd 11 8/25/17 7:41 PM
xii Kagin’s Auctions
Terms and Conditions of Sale (Continued)
10. Buyer’s Commission and Taxes. THE PURCHASE PRICE FOR ALL LOTS INCLUDES THE SUCCESSFUL BID PLUS A
BUYER’S COMMISSION OF 17 1/2%, except as otherwise provided by written agreement between a bidder and KA. Bidders
acknowledge that they are responsible for all sales, use or other taxes applicable to their purchases, and for any interest or
penalty related to unpaid tax, regardless of whether KA collected such taxes at the time of purchase.
11. Kagin’s Loyalty Discount. All successful purchasers shall be entitled to a credit against any future
purchases in a KA auction, in the amount of one percent (1%) of the total purchase prices paid by
them (hammer plus buyer’s commission – taxes or other charges not included), such credit to extend to the next two (2) KA
auctions, or a period of 1 year, whichever is longer.
12. Payment, Risk of Loss and Remedies for Late Payment/Security Interest. After the auction, all successful
purchasers will receive an invoice from KA detailing their purchases and the date payment is due. Title and risk of loss to
goods passes when the purchase price is paid in full, and KA reserves the right to withhold delivery of lots until full payment
is made in good funds. Payment is by cash or credit card payable through a U.S. bank only, unless otherwise agreed in
writing between the buyer and KA. Purchasers agree that if payment is not made in full in accordance with the invoice
terms, they will be liable to KA for interest on the unpaid balance at the rate of 1 1/2% per month (or the maximum rate
permitted by law, whichever is lower), and for reimbursement of all collection costs incurred by KA (including the costs of
engaging an attorney and pursuing legal proceedings). In addition to the foregoing, purchasers grant KA a security interest
in any items purchased by them, to secure any outstanding indebtedness to KA (whether from purchase of the items
themselves or other items), and agree to execute such documents as KA may deem needed to evidence this security interest.
Purchasers agree that KA may exercise all the rights of a secured party, including the right to re-sell the collateral item(s) and
apply the proceeds to purchaser’s debt and to reimbursing KA for costs related to the resale.
13. Limited Return Privilege. Items may not be returned for any reason if they have been certified by a third party
certification service, if the purchaser is a dealer or has presented KA with a valid resale certificate, or if the purchaser viewed
the item prior to the purchase. In all other cases, returns are accepted provided each of the following conditions is met: (1)
the purchaser contends that the item is counterfeit, contains an altered date or mintmark, or contains undisclosed repairs;
(2) the purchaser notifies KA in writing of his or her contention within five (5) days of receiving the item (if purchaser did
not timely pay for the item, his or her return privilege is waived); and (3) the item is returned in its original, sealed and
unopened container. Notwithstanding the above, coin returns are not accepted in cases involving cleaning, artificial toning,
provenance or pedigree, or strike, or whether a coin is a proof.
14. No Rights for Subsequent Purchasers or Assignees. Only the actual purchaser of an item at a KA auction
may claim any rights under these Terms and Conditions, and such rights may not be transferred or assigned to anyone else.
15. Disclaimer of Compensatory, Incidental or Consequential Damages. KA’s liability to purchasers for
returned items, items to which title issues are raised, or in connection with any claim arising from the purchase of an item
at a KA auction is limited to reimbursing the purchaser for the sums actually paid to KA for the item(s) (including buyer’s
commission and taxes), and KA DISCLAIMS ANY LIABILITY FOR COMPENSATORY, INCIDENTAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL
DAMAGES ARISING FROM PURCHASE OF ANY ITEM AT AN KA AUCTION.
16. California Law/Arbitration of All Disputes. These Terms and Conditions shall be construed and enforced
in accordance with California law (excluding choice of law rules). Any claim or controversy arising out of or involving an
KA auction or any provision of Terms and Conditions shall be resolved by arbitration in California through the Professional
Numismatists Guild, with the prevailing party being entitled to an award of its attorney’s fees and costs. Judgment upon an
arbitration award may be entered in any court of competent jurisdiction.